The Rise of Whatnot: Live Shopping’s New Frontier
Whatnot, a Culver City startup founded in 2019, has transformed live shopping into a spectator sport, reaching $8 billion in sales in 2025 and a $20 billion valuation. The platform allows sellers to host live auctions on everything from vintage watches to Pokémon cards, creating a high-energy, interactive experience that has captivated millions. With over 20 million new accounts added last year alone, Whatnot is on track to surpass $1 billion in revenue this year, claiming roughly 60% of the live-commerce market in North America and Europe. But as the platform grows, so do concerns about its impact on users, with critics pointing to high-pressure countdowns and swipe-to-bid designs that encourage overspending and even addiction.
Whatnot’s success lies in its ability to make shopping feel like entertainment. Sellers, ranging from former entertainment workers to small-business owners, use live auctions to build audiences and businesses. The platform’s fast-paced format, with countdown timers and interactive chat rooms, creates a sense of urgency that keeps viewers engaged. However, this same design has raised alarms among consumer advocates and researchers, who warn that the line between shopping and gambling is becoming dangerously blurred.
How Whatnot Works: Swipe, Bid, Repeat
At its core, Whatnot is designed for ease and speed. Users browse live streams featuring sellers hawking items like trading cards, designer fashion, and even instant ramen. Bidding is as simple as a single swipe, and auctions often last mere seconds. The most feverish sales come from “breaks,” where sellers open packs of cards live and buyers purchase spots for a chance at valuable pulls. This format, while exciting, shares similarities with gambling: buyers pay for a randomized outcome, hoping for a big win but often ending up with something worth far less.
Whatnot disputes the gambling comparison, emphasizing that users always receive a physical item. Yet the platform’s design removes nearly all friction from shopping. There’s no time to research market prices, and the countdown timer pressures users into split-second decisions. As one user described, “It does get addicting because it’s like you’re getting stuff on sale, even though you’re still spending money.” This frictionless experience, combined with the thrill of the chase, has led some users to spend beyond their means, with reports of individuals racking up debts exceeding $1 million.
The Dark Side of Frictionless Spending
While Whatnot has empowered many sellers to build thriving businesses, it has also left a trail of financial ruin for some users. The Wall Street Journal profiled Sean Harding, an accountant who spent $1.4 million on baseball cards in just 43 days. Harding, who had no prior history of addiction, described his behavior as akin to gambling, chasing losses and using credit cards and personal loans to fund his bids. His story is not isolated; dozens of users have shared similar experiences on forums like Reddit, describing how the app’s dopamine triggers and fear of missing out kept them trapped in a cycle of overspending.
Critics point to features like mystery boxes and breaks, which mimic slot machines, as particularly harmful. Dr. Mark Griffiths, a professor of behavioral addiction, noted that “everything is designed to keep you on the app, which is potentially rewarding but also addictive.” Whatnot’s CEO rejects the gambling label, citing optional spending controls and a high App Store rating, but consumer protection attorneys have filed arbitration demands alleging that the platform operates an illegal lottery under California law. The debate over whether Whatnot is a shopping app or a gambling den continues to intensify.
Regulatory and Legal Challenges Ahead
As Whatnot’s popularity soars, so does scrutiny from regulators and legal experts. A consumer protection attorney has filed arbitration demands on behalf of more than 70 clients, alleging that Whatnot’s card breaks constitute illegal lotteries and that the company operates a criminal enterprise in violation of racketeering laws. The complaint argues that Whatnot functions as an online casino without the safeguards required of regulated gambling operations. Whatnot categorically denies these claims, maintaining that users always receive a physical item and that the platform is a marketplace, not a gambling site.
However, the legal landscape is murky. The line between shopping and gambling is often defined by whether the outcome is based on chance or skill. In breaks, buyers pay for a random portion of a pack, with the value of their haul determined by luck. This randomness, combined with the high-pressure environment, has led some experts to compare Whatnot to sports betting apps. As state attorneys general and federal regulators begin to take notice, Whatnot may soon face tougher oversight, forcing the company to adapt its practices or risk significant legal repercussions.
Whatnot’s Response: Safety Measures and Controls
In response to growing criticism, Whatnot has introduced several safety measures. Users can set spending and watch time limits, and the company recently rolled out a tool that pauses spending immediately. Whatnot says it plans to test an option to add a passcode before purchases, introducing more friction, and to flag users who show sudden spikes in spending. The company also emphasizes its trust and safety efforts, with over 30% of employees working in that area and using identity verification, automated detection, and human review to stop bad actors.
Whatnot points to its high buyer return rate and seller ratings as evidence that users feel safe on the platform. Yet critics argue that these measures are insufficient, especially since spending limits are optional and easily changed. For users like Vanessa Veliz, who deleted the app to avoid temptation, the allure of a deal is too strong. “It does get addicting,” she said. As Whatnot continues to grow, the company must balance innovation with responsibility, ensuring that its platform remains a fun and safe space for shopping without becoming a haven for compulsive behavior.
The Future of Live Shopping: Innovation vs. Responsibility
Whatnot’s meteoric rise reflects a broader shift in e-commerce toward live, interactive experiences. With competitors like TikTok and Amazon entering the space, the live shopping market is poised for explosive growth. Whatnot’s success lies in its ability to combine entertainment with commerce, creating a sense of community that keeps users coming back. But as the platform scales, it must confront the unintended consequences of its design. The same features that make shopping exciting—countdowns, swipe-to-bid, and live interaction—can also foster unhealthy habits.
Finding the right balance will be crucial. Whatnot has taken steps to address concerns, but whether these measures are enough remains to be seen. The company’s willingness to test new controls, like passcodes and spending alerts, suggests a recognition of the problem. However, real change may require a fundamental rethink of how the app incentivizes spending. As the live shopping industry evolves, Whatnot’s journey will serve as a cautionary tale—and a blueprint—for how to innovate responsibly in the attention economy.
