The scandal that shook The Try Guys
When The Try Guys announced on September 27, 2022, that co-creator Ned Fulmer was no longer with the group, fans were stunned. The decision came after Fulmer admitted to a "consensual workplace relationship" with an employee, confirming rumors that had been swirling for weeks. The group's statement cited a "thorough internal review" and stated they did "not see a path forward together." Fulmer's own statement, posted to Instagram, expressed remorse: "Family should have always been my priority, but I lost focus and had a consensual workplace relationship. I'm sorry for any pain that my actions may have caused to the guys and the fans but most of all to Ariel."
The revelations sent shockwaves through the YouTube community, as Fulmer had built his brand around being the devoted "Wife Guy." The news raised questions about workplace ethics, power dynamics, and the future of the popular group.
Who is Ned Fulmer and what was his role in The Try Guys?
Ned Fulmer was a founding member of The Try Guys, a YouTube channel that started at BuzzFeed in 2014. Alongside Keith Habersberger, Zach Kornfeld, and Eugene Lee Yang, Fulmer helped propel the group to massive success. Their relatable, often humorous content—testing everything from underwear to labor pain—amassed millions of subscribers. Fulmer was also an executive producer and co-owner of Second Try, LLC, the company behind The Try Guys' content.
Beyond his professional role, Fulmer was known for his marriage to Ariel Fulmer, his high school sweetheart. The couple's relationship became central to the group's brand. They co-authored a cookbook, "The Date Night Cookbook," and hosted a podcast, "Baby Steps," about parenting. Ariel, along with the other "Try Wives," frequently appeared in videos, solidifying the image of The Try Guys as a wholesome, family-friendly brand. Fulmer's "Wife Guy" persona made the news of his infidelity all the more shocking to fans.
Timeline of the affair and internal investigation
The scandal didn't unfold overnight. In the weeks leading up to the announcement, fans noticed Fulmer's absence from the group's videos, podcast episodes, and social media. Speculation grew, especially after Reddit users shared photos of Fulmer engaging in "public romantic behavior" with an associate producer, Alex Herring, over Labor Day weekend. The Try Guys addressed the rumors in a video titled "what happened," released on October 3, 2022.
In the video, Keith Habersberger explained that fans alerted them to the behavior, prompting them to reach out to the employee. Fulmer confirmed the relationship, which had been ongoing "for some time." The group then enlisted employment and corporate lawyers, HR, and PR professionals to conduct a three-week investigation. During that time, Fulmer was removed from all work activities and edited out of upcoming videos. The investigation concluded with Fulmer's removal from the company on September 16, though the public statement was delayed until September 27 to handle the situation privately.
The Try Guys' official statements and fan reaction
The Try Guys' initial statement was brief but decisive: "Ned Fulmer is no longer working with The Try Guys. As a result of a thorough internal review, we do not see a path forward together. We thank you for your support as we navigate this change." The group's transparency in the subsequent video, where they expressed a range of emotions from anger to sadness, was praised by many fans. They emphasized that the decision was not taken lightly and that they had no prior knowledge of the affair.
Fulmer's statement came shortly after, taking full responsibility. He apologized to his fans, his colleagues, and especially his wife, stating that his focus would now be on his marriage and children. Ariel Fulmer also released a statement, requesting privacy for the sake of their family. The reaction from the fan community was mixed—some expressed disappointment and anger, while others offered support to Ariel and the remaining Try Guys. The scandal also sparked broader conversations about infidelity, workplace ethics, and the pressure of maintaining a public image.
The legal and ethical implications of consensual workplace relationships
While the relationship was consensual, the power imbalance between Fulmer, an executive producer and co-owner, and the associate producer raised ethical and legal concerns. Even when a relationship is consensual, the dynamics of supervisor-subordinate relationships can create liability for companies. The Try Guys' swift action—launching an internal review and engaging legal counsel—demonstrated their commitment to addressing the situation responsibly.
Legal experts noted that consensual workplace relationships, particularly those involving power imbalances, can lead to claims of favoritism or even sexual harassment if the relationship sours. While Title VII of the Civil Rights Act does not typically cover consensual relationships, companies can mitigate risks by implementing clear policies, requiring disclosure, and providing training. The Try Guys' response set an example for other organizations: take allegations seriously, act quickly, and prioritize transparency. Their handling of the affair may serve as a case study in crisis management for years to come.
What's next for Ariel and Ned Fulmer?
As of now, Ariel and Ned Fulmer remain married, though their relationship is undoubtedly under strain. In the immediate aftermath, Ariel stated that "nothing is more important to me and Ned than our family" and asked for privacy. The couple has two young children, and Fulmer has expressed that his priority is his family. However, whether they will stay together long-term is uncertain. Ariel has since returned to social media, sharing glimpses of her life and focusing on her own projects.
Ned Fulmer has largely stayed out of the public eye, and it's unclear what his next career move will be. The Try Guys, meanwhile, have continued to produce content as a trio, navigating the loss of a founding member. Their video "what happened" has garnered millions of views, and the group has pledged to move forward with the support of their fans. The scandal has left fans wondering about forgiveness, redemption, and the complexities of public personas versus private lives.
Lessons learned: the impact on The Try Guys and beyond
The Try Guys' handling of the scandal offers valuable lessons for other creators and companies. First, brand authenticity is fragile; Fulmer's "Wife Guy" image made the betrayal feel personal to fans. Second, swift and transparent communication can help rebuild trust. The group's willingness to admit they were also shocked and hurt resonated with audiences. Third, workplace relationships require clear boundaries, especially when power dynamics are at play.
Looking ahead, The Try Guys will continue to evolve, now as a trio. Their ability to adapt and maintain their audience's loyalty will depend on their content and integrity. For Ned Fulmer, the road to redemption is long, and only time will tell if he can repair his personal and professional life. The scandal serves as a reminder that even the most carefully crafted images can crumble in an instant, and that accountability is paramount. As fans, we're left to reflect on the human side of fame—and the importance of empathy in the face of imperfection.
